Did BlackNight rip?

[WhiteRanger]

well idk, it looks like he ripped idk

http://masteralex1337.deviantart.com/
Look at c4d wall and look at his sig:
http://i38.tinypic.com/15ryvb5.png

[BloodRedSun]

No you idiot. It says right in the info for that piece...

"I got the render from [link] (http://xbry89x.deviantart.com/art/C4D-Concept-Pack-61223270)"

[WhiteRanger]

it looks like he ripped, if he didn't my bad :|, but look at the spots thier the same thing.

[Almost]

Since when is using a C4D ripping?
Cuz if it is, I've ripped on every sig I've made.

EDIT: he could have used it as a stock, the BG is the same.

[WhiteRanger]

all he did was put a render in the freggin c4d :|, if not il delete my post :\

[37]

background and wireframe look alike

[BloodRedSun]

No... he just downloaded the pack that that C4D was in.

Is it that hard to understand?!

[JediLucas5]

He ripped the guys piece. Look at the BG, it's exactly the same.

Tell the artist. See if he cares that the stock was ripped.

[BloodRedSun]

Well actually yes, now that I look at it thats what he did.

But the person he ripped from didn't own the C4D in the first place.

So it really doesn't matter.

[37]

Well actually yes, now that I look at it thats what he did.

But the person he ripped from didn't own the C4D in the first place.

So it really doesn't matter.

yea but it was a resource and he made a piece of work. and bn maybe took that.

[Almost]

I already said the bg was the same, and that he probably just used it as a stock, but if the guyhe used it from didn't even own it, is it total ripping?
cuz I don't think it is, but I'm major noob at GFX.

[M1dnightCobra]

it does look like he used the stock...unless thats just the whole c4d..and plus its the same bg sooo yaa....all he did was add render, text, square boxes, and some dots..

[BloodRedSun]

The guy who you are saying BN ripped from put the piece up for dload.

Besides, he never said it couldn't be used. He also most likely owned none of the resources used in making the piece. So really, there was no ripping involved.

[Almost]

The guy who you are saying BN ripped from put the piece up for dload.

Besides, he never said it couldn't be used. He also most likely owned none of the resources used in making the piece. So really, there was no ripping involved.
Helps me alot to, I didn't want to be accused of ripping on any piece I make when I post any :P

But yeah...

[WhiteRanger]

Artist Wont Respond.

[pwned0wned]

]

let blacknight respond and provides us with a .psd.

[SmoothPens69]

]

let blacknight respond and provides us with a .psd.

I believe it's a rip because it's a piece not a c4d. The guy made it from a c4d pack, so it's his art. Blacknight, read the stuff below the art.

[pwned0wned]

I believe it's a rip because it's a piece not a c4d. The guy made it from a c4d pack, so it's his art. Blacknight, read the stuff below the art.

i know but if he responds and gives us the .psd from there we could know

just let him respond ,

i also do believe its a rip.Just let him provide us with a .psd or a simply an answer

[wut]

I think its a layer rip.

But lets just wait for his response.

[blondie]

Hahaha, I doubt the psd was released.


I'm 95% sure it's a rip since all the spots on the dA piece are the same.


In case you're new or are mentally handicapped somewhat, you can't take other people's artwork as stocks. All dA peices are up for download. Just fyi.

[pwned0wned]

whoops edit:

[Stonch]

I used more then one cd4 noob.
I used 3 cd4's and some lighting and some other stuff.

And i found that cd4 so i used it! What's wrong with that?

[WhiteRanger]

HE has spoken, i asked, and they answered.

[37]

HE has spoken, i asked, and they answered.

okay heres blacknights..

http://i38.tinypic.com/15ryvb5.png

notice the bottom where the wire frame is. its exactly alike

[Buttercup]

You guys.. This is sad.


A while ago, ripping was taking the tag and using it as yours. Now if you use a c4d or a render/stock or whatever.. Thats ripping? Its using it. Its like I take a c4d from someone and say I made that c4d.. Thats ripping, because I said I made it. He was just using it. A resource.

People take screenies of clan skins or banners and make them into sigs/ubs.. Is that ripping? Because thats basicly the same thing

You guys make a big deal over nothing. "OMG WTF!!! he used the same stock as me! >:|"

[wut]

I used more then one cd4 noob.
I used 3 cd4's and some lighting and some other stuff.

And i found that cd4 so i used it! What's wrong with that?

Can you provide us with a .psd?

[SuperDX]

Can you provide us with a .psd?


What you mean!
I just told you i used the CD4, Big deal.

[wut]

What you mean!
I just told you i used the CD4, Big deal.

are you blacknight?

[Almost]

are you blacknight?
Apparently he is lol.
but if he refuses to give up a PSD, that just makes me think he did more.
but if using C4Ds is ripping then I'ma quit GFX now.

[SmoothPens69]

Apparently he is lol.
but if he refuses to give up a PSD, that just makes me think he did more.
but if using C4Ds is ripping then I'ma quit GFX now.

Hey guys, I'm not calling you dumb, but once again i will post...

He used an art piece that a guy made from c4ds. It wasn't a c4d he used. IT WAS AN ART PIECE MADE FROM C4DS. SO THAT'S RIPPING

[wut]

Apparently he is lol.
but if he refuses to give up a PSD, that just makes me think he did more.
but if using C4Ds is ripping then I'ma quit GFX now.

Using c4ds isn't ripping.

Hey guys, I'm not calling you dumb, but once again i will post...

He used an art piece that a guy made from c4ds. It wasn't a c4d he used. IT WAS AN ART PIECE MADE FROM C4DS. SO THAT'S RIPPING

Yes we understand that.

We are just waiting for a reply from him.

[Almost]

Hey guys, I'm not calling you dumb, but once again i will post...

He used an art piece that a guy made from c4ds. It wasn't a c4d he used. IT WAS AN ART PIECE MADE FROM C4DS. SO THAT'S RIPPING

Hi iRock, still ban evading I see.

[two11isnothappy]

BN, you ripped.

And, hahaha!

You just took the LP added a sprite, and then called it your own.
Jeeze, dont lie.

[Darkthought]

Hm doesn't seem like too much happened during my inactivity

[two11isnothappy]

Hm doesn't seem like too much happened during my inactivity

I QUIT. FOREVER.
I got staff on PR...


http://www.pawngame.com/forum/showthread.php?t=78273
http://www.pawngame.com/forum/showthread.php?t=78273
http://www.pawngame.com/forum/showthread.php?t=78273
http://www.pawngame.com/forum/showthread.php?t=78273
http://www.pawngame.com/forum/showthread.php?t=78273
http://www.pawngame.com/forum/showthread.php?t=78273
http://www.pawngame.com/forum/showthread.php?t=78273
http://www.pawngame.com/forum/showthread.php?t=78273
http://www.pawngame.com/forum/showthread.php?t=78273
http://www.pawngame.com/forum/showthread.php?t=78273
http://www.pawngame.com/forum/showthread.php?t=78273
http://www.pawngame.com/forum/showthread.php?t=78273

[Eiliosdraye]

BN, why would you rip? Come on, that's stupid.

[Stonch]

Lol you guys are going crazy over a rip lol

Every one makes mistakes.

[Claw]

It really doesn't matter if he ripped or not. No one gives a crap.

[troll]

It really doesn't matter if he ripped or not. No one gives a crap.
Did we ask for your opinion?

Most people care.

[Claw]

Did we ask for your opinion?

Most people care.
Why is that?

[Stonch]

It really doesn't matter if he ripped or not. No one gives a crap.

Lol, To some people it's like the end of the world.

[troll]

Why is that?
Don't post here if you aren't interested in graphics.

[wut]

Lol you guys are going crazy over a rip lol

Every one makes mistakes.




Ripper!!!!!!!!!

No just kidding.

Oh well.

Case closed.

[Andrew02111]

Meh I don't really care tbh. But I got to say, I am a bit disappointed at BN as a gfxer.

I used to look up to him.

Really its only the internet, Anything can happen here. He ripped so everyone get over it.